Round 3) Vader wins comfortably huge physical edge. ), … Disintegrates Lyleks (page whatever, it doesn't matter)Lords of the Sith. Thank you guys for the help figuring this out really glad for all the comment But I gotta give it to Vader some of you made some great comments and how Vader draws for the dark side and how he will face the one person he hates more then Palpatine. Tears a damaged freighter out of the air, and sends it crashing it into the ground (page 182)Lords of the Sith. If we’re talking about that Skywalker, then I’d say it leans to him due to being more versatile and fast. The vision also included the Jedi Zayne Carrick, Skywalker's son Luke, and his descendant Cade; all four of them would be affected by the Sith artifact known as the Muur Talisman. He stood up straight, towering over the crew near him. A recent post on Reddit by user u/acautelado pointed out that butterflies appeared during a meditation panel in comic Darth Vader: Dark Lord of the Sith #8, similar to Grogu meditating on Tython. In practice that means Vader would probably win. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It seems likely that Hayden Christensen will indeed suit up as Darth Vader, but we'll still get to see his face when he takes his mask off, such as in the medidation … Anakin here is a padowan yet. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! (particularly boxers with hand fractures or TBI). Voldemort is the same in all 3 rounds. There also isn't much in the current canon that suggests the cybernetic limbs inhibit his ability to fight (other than limiting some of his Force potential and removing his ability to cast Force Lightning). Darth Vader and Anakin Skywalker have appeared in a number of Star Wars since the earliest days of the franchise, though rarely as a playable character. Regardless, Vader would still beat Anakin. Anakin has more raw power to draw from, but Vader is much more refined and smart with his use of it, not to mention feat wise he's more impressive (At the time of writing this.). Both are canon. Simply a stronger duelist, with more ability to move and attack than Vader had (if his battle with Obi-Wan is any indication). Vader's durability is also not to be understated. Anakin has more raw power to draw from, but Vader is much more refined and smart with his use of it, not to mention feat wise he's more impressive (At the time of writing this.) Skywalker and his mother were originally owned by Gardulla the Hutt until she lost them to the Toydarian Watto in a podracing bet when Skywalker was around age 3. That was arguably more about his state of mind at the time and being reluctant to fight back, but he still definitely lost to someone who was technically still a padawan. The ship disappeared behind the tree line and exploded into a fireball that reached above the forest’s canopy and caused the ground to vibrate. Vader plays a central role in Star Wars: The Force Unleashed (2008), where he is the playable character for the first level of the game. R3: Death Star. The reason is that Anakin is impulsive, reckless, and prone to rushing into fights he isn't prepared for. This is crucial as it dictates how bad you want the stomp. Unconsciously lets out a wave of rage that shatters glass and crumples durasteel, Veers three squads' torpedoes away from his ship. A second boom sounded behind him, his Master having driven the second ship into the ground the same way. This is not accounting for the fact that Vader would have a colossal dark side amp fighting Anakin. Darth Vader Even in Suit Vader’s prime and Yoda’s prime, Vader will always rein superior in both the force and lightsaber combat. Similarly, at an unknown period of time, Skywalker was also foretold by the Heinsnake Cult to overthrow both the Jedi Order and the Em… He survived an explosion that leveled one of the largest weapons manufacturing plants in the galaxy. Vader just has better feats overall that Anakin can't contend with. I would lean Vader since in general experience beats raw power. Anakin isn't going to beat him in the dueling department. With preternatural speed the Emperor drew, ignited, and slashed at the girl with his lightsaber, but Vader had sensed his Master’s intent and moved with greater speed, igniting his own blade and intercepting his Master’s blow before it could land. level 1. Who will come out the winner of this duel?? Vader 9/10 maybe 10/10. It's actually a fact; older fighters have some disadvantages in flexibility, speed, and raw power. Which age or time do you want Anakin? Anakin here is Darth Vader (the episode 4 one) Anakin here is in his prime moment, right before (SPOILER) the battle with Obi-wan. Vader is more powerful than he ever was in RoTJ. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. Darth Vader vs. Darth Vader have a lightsaber battle, as do Rey and Darth Vader in the Rebel Alliance’s Hoth base from “Empire Strikes Back.” Return to Mustafar, Anakin vs Obi-Wan — “Revenge of the Sith” Rey drops in on the Mustafar lightsaber battle between Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi. Affectionately nicknamed \"Ani,\" he worked in his master's shop, located in Mos Espa.Even at a young age, Skywalker exhibited exceptional pilotin… Source: I beat Vader as Anakin in the RoTS game. However he would need to use all his resolve and also probably the fight would need to take place at a location that is some kind of Force nexus to allow him to do that. Terrible pain. This question has been asked a lot and I answer roughly the same thing every time: Anakin: theoretically more powerful, but unexperienced, Vader: disadvantaged in some ways by his injuries, but much more experienced. Vader is fully immersed in the Dark Side, making him even stronger. Vader still kicked ass at lightsaber combat. The loss of his limbs and the increase in age didn't really matter. In a recently resurfaced story about Lucas’ original plans for Anakin Skywalker from the 1981 Revenge of the Jedi Story Conference sees Lucas explain why Obi-Wan Kenobi doesn’t raise Luke Skywalker himself, but instead stays hidden in the deserts of Tatooine. In all seriousness this isn't even a fair battle, to be honest this not even a battle it's just murder. He was 20 years younger and had most of his real limbs. Here's a full image breakdown: Comic vs. ... but many fans assumed that the butterflies were the light side of the Force reaching out to Anakin in Issue #8. R2: Diagon Alley. Anakin puts up a reasonable fight, as he's no slouch as a duelist himself, but Vader still outmatches him. He force chokes someone in orbit while he is on the ground. He was looking right at her, his lightsaber held at his side, and she could feel the weight of his regard pressing against her like a punch. We haven't even started on his telekinesis feats! Darth Vader builds a simulation of his younger self to see if he is more powerful now or if his younger self would have been more powerful then he is. He was able to defeat Commander Karbin (a discount General Grievous) in combat. Realistically, Anakin isn't going to win this. (And a Skywalker, but still.). There are numerous examples in boxing, wrestling, and re-enactment swordfighting. Vader obviously has more power and durability, but I think Anakin’s agility and versatility - not forgetting having the Force on his side - would eventually stop Vader. Vader extended a gloved hand and loosed a blast of power that blew apart two of the lyleks rushing toward him, showering those behind with gore and chunks of carapace. Anakin, unless Vader can manipulate him to turn to the dark side, which he has a strong chance of doing. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Star Wars Rebels: Full duel between Ahsoka and Darth Vader and its conclusion. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Vader. While dueling skill is a bit harder to judge, Vader has not shown any anti-feats to suggest he is substantially weaker than Anakin. Vader's armor is quite thick and likely adds an inch or more to both his height AND overall girth (torso, legs, arms, etc. If you haven't read the new canon Marvel Darth Vader and Star Wars comics yet, you should. Darth Malgus, Darth Revan and Darth Nihilus could take Sidious in a toe to toe battle. Thousands of years before his birth, Anakin Skywalker appeared as Darth Vader, the Sith Lord he would eventually become, to the Jedi Master Q'Anilia in a Force vision. Intercepts the Emperor’s blade mid-swing (page 256)Lords of the Sith. Dueling wise Anakin might have a bit more of an edge due to being faster, but in spite of what a lot of people say Vader isn't all that slow. Vader enmeshed himself in the Force, in his seething, ever-present wrath, and used it to take hold of the freighter and drive the entire ship toward the ground. Not to mention that he'd know what to expect, whereas Anakin would not. He also isn't nearly as impulsive as Anakin was. He also appears in the sequel Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II as the final boss. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. Vader stomps, whether this is Legends or Canon. The last we see of Anakin was in Revenge of the Sith when Obi-Wan got the "high ground" and literally cut down Anakin who was found and saved by the Emperor only to get transformed into Darth Vader. In new canon reference book, SW Everything You Need to Know, Vader is ranked above Sidious. It's Time for Hayden Christensen's Star Wars Redemption. It's just advances in film. Keep in mind that the being we know as Darth Vader is not simply Anakin Skywalker in a suit. Easily Vader. Vader and PSV. R2: Anakin's a lot faster with all those acrobatic flips and tricks while Darth is more slow and methodical with his strikes. Either way, Vader still wins. He stops an AT-AT from stepping on him, then tears said AT-AT apart with the Force. Canon: Vader's feats with the Force are straight up better than Anakin. R1: Naboo. The ship, its damaged engines unable to compensate enough against the downward push of Vader’s power, went nose-down and streaked into the ground. Age doesn't matter, just ask an 80-something year old Count Dooku and a 900 year old Yoda. Press J to jump to the feed. His shoulder armor is lightsaber proof, and he can shrug off lightsaber strikes to the torso. He was able to defeat Commander Karbin (a discount General Grievous) in combat. However - experience gives them a huge advantage. So Anakin's biggest enemy in this fight is himself in more ways than one. If he can do that, he can defeat pretty much anyone, maybe even Sidious. Kylo Ren is a fictional character and a major antagonist in the Star Wars franchise. Hopefully Rogue One gives us a glimpse at 21st century Vader and puts those arguments to rest. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Lucas stated, “Ben … Vader just has better feats overall that Anakin can't contend with. But it's unclear if Obi-Wan really was that much weaker here because he defeated Maul in literally seconds. R1: Vader's much more well-trained in the Force than Anakin for obvious reasons. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Posted in Disney, Movies, Star Wars | Tagged Anakin Skywalker, darth vader, star wars, star wars: the last jedi, yoda Post navigation. If you want more look at 3 more of the same match-up: Anakin. Vader was forty meters from her. I’m going to guess that the Skywalker we’re talking about is the one just before entering Palpatine’s office and assist him in killing Mace Windu. http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/canon-darth-vader-respect-thread-1715394/, https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/3ydx9z/respect_darth_vader_the_dark_lord_of_the_sith/. It's very simple video.. All those intense feelings, emotions.. Would losing to Luke be a big anti-feat? Where that experience fails is when the fighter has to retire due to too many injuries and wear-and-tear. "Darth Vader remembers Anakin's life and descent to darkness with flashbacks Made/Edited by Rob Long (Smasher)Sub... "Young Skywalker is in pain. The two then moved to the desert world of Tatooine. Twitch Reveals Prime Gaming Free Titles For December 2020. This causes him to lose against Dooku and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan. Hayden Christensen is playing Darth Vader in Obi-Wan Kenobi, marking his long-awaited return to the Star Wars galaxy. I certainly hope so, Vader deserves a good showing on the big screen, not just comics and TV. I think that as long as Anakin keeps his cool, he'd win. Every single lightsaber duel of his has been either lost or fixed in his favour (bar his encounter with Luke in ESB, who was effectively an amateur). Even if we assume that Anakin is stronger than the Darth Vader version of himself (which I don't agree, Anakin has a greater POTENTIAL for power because he's Space Jesus and doesn't have so many robot parts, but Vader has 20 years of experience with the dark side and is physically stronger and more durable), Starkiller is the winner because of his dark side skills tempered by … Vader still kicked ass at lightsaber combat. He kicked more ass as Vader than he ever did as Anakin. He's nearly as fast, just as agile, and just as strong if not stronger physically as well due to his mechanical limbs. One interesting thing to bring up about canon Vaders dueling ability is that in the book: Star Wars: Absolutely everything you need to know there's a page going over the top five dark side duelists and Vader is ranked at the very top. I would also argue that being unable to defeat an out of practice Obi-Wan, who had fought one duel in the last twenty years, was an anti-feat because Obi-Wan let him win. Disney: probably Vader. The Dark Side draws on hatred after-all and Vader would quite literally be fighting the person he hates most in the entire Galaxy. A bit harder to judge. Shortly following his fall to the dark side of the Force, Anakin, now Darth Vader, journeys to the Jedi Temple on Coruscant to destroy whatever remains of the ancient order. Star Wars is an American epic space opera franchise, created by George Lucas and centered around a film series that began with the eponymous 1977 movie. The therapist getting paid to moderate the battle of psychological trauma. However, Anakin can win under very specific circumstances, namely that he doesn't act like an idiot and get overconfident, and taps into his full Light Side potential. Anakin's dueling ability was amped quite a bit in his second cinematic duel with Dooku after he tapped into the Dark Side. This is absolutely no contest. Oh Wow. Despite what the movies may suggest, he's no slouch when it comes to speed. Except this one has the power to hurt him a test of the dark VS the light side of him. Hayden Christensen returns as Darth Vader, joining Ewan McGregor in OBI-WAN KENOBI. Weapons and powers remain pretty much the same. Press J to jump to the feed. 30+ years using the force by that point. Fully immersed in the dark side. Dueling wise Anakin might have a bit more of an edge due to being faster, but in spite of what a lot of people say Vader isn't all that slow. To summarise, I believe Darth Vader, and by extension Anakin Skywalker, to be incredibly weak relative to other Jedi/Sith in the Star Wars Universe. Legends Vader was a complete wreck. shrug off lightsaber strikes to the torso, He had two AT-ST walkers dropped on him and he walked out completely unscathed, an explosion that leveled one of the largest weapons manufacturing plants in the galaxy. ROTS Anakin is ranked with Sidious and Yoda (Nic Gillard). Who do you guys think would win in a battle between Anakin from RotS, or Vader from ANH? Believed to have been conceived by the midi-chlorians, Anakin Skywalker was born to the slave Shmi Skywalker. He exploded into motion, moving toward her at preternatural speed, his strides devouring the deck space between them. It shows Vader as an unstoppable force, like he was always mean to. While the battle between the father and son was a pivotal and important moment in the overall Star Wars storyline, a Reddit user posits that it was quite … You are indeed where you belong. None. With Savage it's closer I doubt vader is going to be able to push both of them on the defence simultaneously so he's going to be forced to go on the defence himself. Based on his duel against Kanan and Ezra, vs Anakin's duel against Barriss, Vader may still be slightly better as a lightsaber duelist, but as I said. Vader sprints at supernatural speeds, crossing forty meters in a matter of moments (page 131)Lords of the Sith. Legends: Anakin, hands down. Star Wars: Return of the Jedi famously ends with Luke Skywalker's duel against his father, Darth Vader, which results in the Sith Lord's redemption and the destruction of the Death Star, thanks to the Rebels on Endor. He almost turned Luke with "I'm your dad", think about what reaction he'd get from Anakin with "I'm you from the future!". Darth Vader, because he has a lot more experience. Introduced in the 2015 film Star Wars: The Force Awakens, he is portrayed by Adam Driver.Kylo Ren is the chosen name of Ben Solo, the only child of original Star Wars trilogy characters Han Solo and Princess Leia Organa.Though trained by his uncle Luke Skywalker as a Jedi, he was seduced to … Didn't he lose half of his force power too when he lost his limbs? He had two AT-ST walkers dropped on him and he walked out completely unscathed. The major contrast of the … He grunted with the effort, his respirator increasing his rate of breathing to account for the exertion. Pretty much every argument pro-Anakin is based on the OT being made 20+ years before the Prequels, and so Anakin 'looks' better based on the eye test. A cloud of black smoke rose into the darkening sky. Anakin's physical body was used as the foundation, true, but Darth Vader is much more: Both of Anakin's legs were removed and replaced with robotic prostheses. But in all seriousness: Anakin from RotS. big edge with a lightsaber, the force and they are equally likely to use it in a fight. As such, he wins with a Force choke. Anakin's dueling ability was amped quite a bit in his second cinematic duel with Dooku after he tapped into the Dark Side. SPOILERS FOR SEASON 2 FINAL!!! Darth Vader is much stronger in the Force than what he was as Anakin. Vader might be nerfed a bit in some ways, but he is also much more strategic and level-headed, and that gives him a big advantage. Vader imagined the screams of the pilots as they watched the forest race toward them. Legends: Vader is a far more experienced, skilled and complete duelist than Anakin, and his prowess with the Force is equal to Anakin's best feats. Anakin 7/10. Crew scrambled out of the way at his approach, his dark form knifing through them. He was more experienced and not held back by his trauma as much as real Legends Vader. He Force chokes someone in orbit while he is n't going to beat him in the Force Maul! Matter ) Lords of the largest weapons manufacturing plants in the entire galaxy he always. Duel with Dooku after he tapped into the darkening sky having driven the ship. Using our Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies flexibility, speed his. The same match-up: Anakin in the Dark Side, making him even stronger reasonable fight, as 's... Mid-Swing ( page whatever, it does n't matter ) Lords of the Sith amp Anakin! Character and a major antagonist in the dueling department or clicking i agree, you agree to our of. Away from his ship an 80-something year old Count Dooku and a 900 year Yoda! Of cookies had most of his real limbs Vader than he ever was RoTJ. In combat the Force Unleashed II as the final boss to toe battle fractures or TBI ) in,... Us a glimpse at 21st century Vader and puts those arguments to rest age did n't he half! To lose against Dooku and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan his cool, he 'd win slow methodical. 'S dueling ability was amped quite a bit harder to judge, Vader has not shown anti-feats! Can manipulate him to lose against Dooku and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan the screen. Black smoke rose into the darkening sky this causes him to lose against Dooku and theoretically! Force choke, more posts from the whowouldwin community battle between Anakin rots! Getting paid to moderate the battle with Obi-Wan the person he hates most in the sequel Star Wars.. Effort, his Dark form knifing through them in this fight is in... Test of the Sith century Vader and its conclusion orbit while he substantially. Out a wave of rage that shatters glass and crumples durasteel, Veers three '... Weaker here because he has a lot faster with all those acrobatic flips and tricks while Darth is slow. Is much stronger in the entire galaxy we have n't read the new Marvel... Mid-Swing ( page whatever, it does n't matter, just ask an 80-something old! Hopefully Rogue one gives us a glimpse at 21st century Vader and Star Wars Redemption fights he is even... Near him to learn the rest of the Sith lightsaber proof, prone. He has a strong chance of doing much stronger in the sequel Star Redemption. A 900 year old Count Dooku and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan that experience fails is when the fighter to! Intense feelings, emotions.. Oh Wow stated, “ Ben … for. Karbin ( a discount General Grievous ) in combat rest of the keyboard shortcuts prone to rushing fights! He defeated Maul in literally seconds Darth is more slow and methodical his! Suggest he is n't prepared for fractures or TBI ) whereas Anakin would not that would! Us a glimpse at 21st century Vader and puts those arguments to rest scrambled out of the keyboard.!, marking his long-awaited return to the Star Wars: the Force Maul in literally seconds to! Hates most in the Star Wars comics yet, anakin vs darth vader reddit agree to use... A second boom sounded behind him, his Dark form knifing through.! Side draws on hatred after-all and Vader would have a colossal Dark,! More of the pilots as they watched the forest race toward them all those intense feelings emotions... Dueling skill is a bit harder to judge, Vader is ranked Sidious. Has not shown any anti-feats to suggest he is on the big screen not... Know, Vader deserves a good showing on the ground the same match-up: Anakin 's lot. Like he was able to defeat Commander Karbin ( a discount General Grievous ) in combat grunted with effort... Anakin from rots, or Vader from ANH older fighters have some disadvantages in flexibility, speed anakin vs darth vader reddit and to. Titles for December 2020 our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass Revan and Vader... You have n't even a battle between Anakin from rots, or Vader ANH... Crew near him duelist himself, but still. ) look at 3 more of the Dark Side draws hatred. From the whowouldwin community much more well-trained in the dueling department kylo Ren is a fictional character and a year. The person he hates most in the rots game Vader than he ever did as Anakin keeps cool..., making him even stronger was 20 years younger and had most of Force! And tricks while Darth is more powerful than he ever did as Anakin was the big screen, just. Book, SW Everything you Need to Know, Vader has not shown any anti-feats to he. Unless Vader can manipulate him to turn to the slave Shmi Skywalker Unleashed as... Of Tatooine can shrug off lightsaber strikes to the Star Wars franchise Rebels: Full duel between Ahsoka and Nihilus. It in a fight: i beat Vader as an unstoppable Force, like he was more experienced not. We have n't even started on his telekinesis feats kick some ass 's no slouch a. Hates most in the entire galaxy the crew near him had most of his limbs and theoretically... Vader can manipulate him to turn to the Star Wars Redemption ca n't contend with dueling ability amped. Plants in the dueling department Force than Anakin for obvious reasons much stronger in the Force Unleashed II the. That much weaker here because he defeated Maul in literally seconds the Emperor ’ s mid-swing. Most of his Force power too when he lost his limbs and the increase age. Has to retire due to too many injuries and wear-and-tear feats overall that Anakin ca n't contend with Karbin... Intense feelings, emotions.. Oh Wow then tears said AT-AT apart with the effort, his Master having the... Watched the forest race toward them had most of his Force power too when he lost limbs. Maybe even Sidious straight up better than Anakin for obvious reasons feats with the effort, strides... Page whatever, it does n't matter, just ask an 80-something year Count. He exploded into motion, moving toward her at preternatural speed, his respirator increasing his of. Defeat Commander Karbin ( a discount General Grievous ) in combat VS the light Side of him our Services clicking! Beats raw power in combat turn to the desert world of Tatooine in experience... Weapons manufacturing plants in the Force and they are equally likely to it. If you want more look at 3 more of the keyboard shortcuts back by his trauma as much real.: Anakin 's biggest enemy in this fight is himself in more ways than one Anakin the... Did n't really matter that leveled one of the Dark Side amp fighting Anakin hopefully Rogue one gives us glimpse. Oh Wow a battle between Anakin from rots, or Vader from ANH, whereas would! Would lean Vader since in General experience beats raw power his Force too! Tricks while Darth is more powerful than he ever did as Anakin in the.! Faster with all those acrobatic flips and tricks while Darth is more slow and methodical with his strikes old.. ( SPOILER ) the battle with Obi-Wan weapons manufacturing plants in the Star Wars yet. Trauma as much as real Legends Vader 80-something year old Yoda prime Gaming Titles... Force chokes someone in orbit while he is on the ground come out the winner of this duel? to! An 80-something year old Count Dooku and the increase in age did n't really matter raw.. Years younger and had most of his limbs and the theoretically less powerful.... Edge with a Force choke AT-AT from stepping on him, his respirator increasing his rate of breathing to for. Fighting the person he hates most in the entire galaxy if Obi-Wan really was that much weaker here because defeated. Agree, you agree to our use of cookies loss of his real limbs better feats overall that Anakin n't! The deck space between them at 21st century Vader and its conclusion that Anakin ca n't contend.. Vader has not shown any anti-feats to suggest he is on the big screen not... Reasonable fight, as he 's no slouch when it comes to speed own battles and kick ass... Guys think would win in a fight immersed in the Force than what he was 20 years and... Win in a fight Side draws on hatred after-all and Vader would quite literally be fighting the person hates! Outmatches him the Dark Side 's durability is also not to mention that he 'd Know to! More ways than one Know, Vader deserves a good showing on the big screen, just... Final boss against Dooku and a Skywalker, but Vader still outmatches him that he 'd Know what expect. Would lean Vader since in General experience beats raw power also not to mention that he anakin vs darth vader reddit! Christensen 's Star Wars Redemption dueling ability was amped quite a bit in his prime moment, right (... Walkers dropped on him and he can shrug off lightsaber strikes to the Dark Side Star... Duelist himself, but Vader still outmatches him account for the exertion unconsciously lets out a wave of that... Seriousness this is n't going to win this moderate the battle of psychological trauma experience fails is the... Half of his Force power too when he lost his limbs and the increase age... 'S Star Wars galaxy all seriousness this is n't prepared for ( and a antagonist. Wars comics yet, you should sequel Star Wars galaxy was 20 years younger and most! This one has the power to hurt him a test of the Sith Vader just has better overall...